ISATIS GROUP Arikeh Sanat IsatisInstrumentation · Control · Safety

Control Valve Selection and Sizing: A Practical Guide for Process Plants

Date
Reading
5 min read
Author
Arikeh engineering team
Metering and prover skid

Process data, Cv sizing, body styles, flow characteristics, actuators, positioners and severe service: what decides whether a control valve controls well.

A control valve is the part of a control loop that actually changes the process. The transmitter can be accurate and the controller well tuned, but if the valve is oversized, sticks, or has the wrong characteristic, the loop will cycle, drift or saturate. Surveys of process plants regularly find that a large share of poorly performing loops trace back to the final control element rather than to tuning.

This guide covers the decisions that decide whether a valve will control well: the process data, sizing, body style and trim, characteristic, actuator and positioner, and the service conditions that destroy valves early.

Get the process data right first

Sizing is only as good as the data sheet behind it. For each valve the process engineer should state the fluid and its properties, and three operating cases at least: minimum, normal and maximum flow, each with the matching upstream pressure, pressure drop and temperature. Shut-off requirements, the allowable noise level at one metre, and any upset or start-up case that differs from normal operation belong on the same sheet. A valve sized only on the normal case often ends up nearly closed at low flow and wide open during an upset.

Sizing with Cv and IEC 60534

Valve capacity is expressed as the flow coefficient Cv (or Kv in metric units). Sizing follows IEC 60534-2-1 or the equivalent ISA-75.01 equations, which account for pressure recovery, choked flow and piping geometry. A few rules keep the result controllable:

  • At maximum flow the valve should be around 70% to 80% open, and at minimum flow not much below 10% to 20%, so that it controls across the whole range.
  • The valve needs a fair share of the system pressure drop. If the valve takes only a small fraction of the loop’s total drop, its installed characteristic flattens and control near full flow becomes poor.
  • Check for choked flow and cavitation in liquids and for sonic velocity and noise in gases at every case, not only at the normal one.
  • A valve body one size smaller than the line, with reducers, is normal and usually better than a line-size valve with a reduced trim.

Body styles and where they fit

Body style Typical use Strengths Limits
Globe (cage or plug guided) General throttling, high pressure drop, severe service Accurate control, wide choice of trims including anti-cavitation and low-noise cages Higher cost and weight in large sizes; lower capacity per size
Eccentric rotary plug Throttling with good shut-off, slurries and dirty fluids High rangeability, compact, tolerates solids better than a cage Fewer options for severe noise or cavitation
Segmented or V-notch ball Fibrous and erosive services, high capacity throttling Shearing action, large capacity, good rangeability Higher pressure recovery makes cavitation more likely
High-performance butterfly Large lines, low pressure drop, cooling water and gas Light, compact and economical in large sizes Limited throttling range and pressure drop; high recovery

Choosing the inherent characteristic

The inherent characteristic describes how flow changes with travel at a constant pressure drop. Equal percentage is the usual choice when the valve takes a small part of the system pressure drop, which covers most pressure and flow loops, because the installed result becomes closer to linear. A linear characteristic suits loops where the valve takes most of the pressure drop, such as many level loops and bypass duties. Quick opening is for on-off and relief duties, not throttling. Whatever is chosen, the gain of the installed valve should stay reasonably constant over the operating range, since that is what the controller tuning assumes.

Actuators and positioners

Spring-and-diaphragm actuators remain the standard for throttling: simple, reliable and with a defined fail position when air is lost. Piston actuators provide more thrust in a smaller package for high shut-off pressures and large rotary valves. The fail action, close, open or stay put, is a process safety decision and must match the hazard analysis, not the catalogue default.

The actuator must be sized for the worst case of unbalanced force plus seat load and packing friction, with margin. A digital positioner then makes the valve respond to small signal changes and provides diagnostics such as travel deviation, friction and air supply pressure through HART or a fieldbus. Valves with a safety function, such as an emergency shutdown valve with a solenoid, are often equipped with partial stroke testing so their ability to move can be proven without stopping the plant.

Severe service: cavitation, flashing and noise

In liquids, cavitation occurs when the pressure inside the valve falls below vapour pressure and then recovers, collapsing the bubbles against the trim and body. The result is noise, vibration and rapid erosion. Flashing, where the pressure does not recover above vapour pressure, causes a different erosion pattern and calls for hardened materials and often an angle body. In gas service, high pressure drop creates aerodynamic noise that can exceed the limit for personnel and fatigue the downstream piping. Multi-stage or anti-cavitation trims, low-noise cages, diffusers and correct downstream pipe sizing are the tools; they are far cheaper to specify at the design stage than to retrofit.

Leakage class and packing

Seat leakage is specified by class under IEC 60534-4 and ANSI/FCI 70-2, from Class IV for most metal-seated control valves to Class V and VI for tight shut-off. Asking for a tighter class than the process needs raises cost and actuator size. Stem packing deserves the same attention: low-emission packing qualified to ISO 15848-1 is increasingly required for volatile hydrocarbons and toxic fluids.

Frequently asked questions

Can a control valve also serve as the shut-off valve?

Sometimes, for non-critical duties, if the leakage class and fail action suit the case. Where isolation is part of a safety function, a dedicated shut-off valve with its own final element and testing regime is the normal practice, so the control function and the safety function remain independent.

Why does a new valve make the loop cycle?

The common causes are oversizing, which leaves the valve working close to its seat with a high gain; stick-slip from tight packing or an undersized actuator; and a characteristic that does not match the installed pressure drop. Positioner diagnostics usually show which one it is.

Arikeh Sanat Isatis supplies control valves, actuators and positioners from manufacturers such as Emerson, SAMSON, Masoneilan and Flowserve, and reviews sizing calculations and data sheets before purchase. See our services or contact us to discuss your valves.

Send us your datasheets, P&IDs or tender documents.

We review them and reply with a technical and commercial proposal.

info@iow.ir +98 21 2205 5712 Request a quote